posted
ukaoha: Thanks for re-directing us to the topic. You failed to acknowledge that I did not start the discussion on I(g)bo. I merely responded. You are on the dot that this does not matter, but you can see that some are averse to my spelling. I cannot help such, neither can they sway me. Primarily because coercion and intimidation have no impressions on my person. Such tactics only work on 'fools'.
Yes, you have listed some good names above. Namely, Emeka Anyaoku et al. My question is: Are the I(g)bo ready for 2003? Suggesting names does not imply that the nominees are willing to run for president. We have to be certain that these individuals are willing before we undertake what may amount to a futile exercise.
Posts: 25 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
posted
For onece I like to seat back and let my brothers and sister here supuru mu okwu Oyibo. Man I am enjoying this debate going on here on BiafraNigeria website message board. This is what we have been missing for a long time a free flowing ideas and debates.
I am appealing to Brother chuba not to take our free for all debate as an attack, This is what the Igbo independent mind is all about. We respect our leaders but we don't worship them like other Nigeria ethnic groups.
Brother Ukaoha I think Your list was very rich, however my best on that list are Dr Ekwueme and Dr Pat Utomi. More over Pat Utomi because of Ekwueme's age and the 1999 debacle in Jos. Anyaoku I am still not sold on him as a true Igbo champion because he didn't stand up to be counted during the time Igbos were in need. He Joined Ukpabia Asika to dine with the enemy. For that I will put him in the same category with Ike Nwachukwu, as those who have to atone for their anti Igbo before we can support them.
As for Pat Utomi and Ekwueme they don't need re-introduction. I gues as we debate this more names will come up. That of Pat Utomi escape me while I was responding to brother Osita.
posted
Biafra: Far from it, I do not see the discussion as a personal attack, but for one fellow who has rigidly refused to see where I am coming from. In fact, he quoted me out of context in order to lend validity to an unnecessary tantrum by him.
Yes, to the topic. Emeka Anyaoku has stated that he is not interested in political office, thus he is out of the picture.
Alex Ekwueme may be the right guy, but I have my fears that the wounds of 1998 are still fresh as to affect his zeal for the presidency come 2003.
John Nnia Nwodo comes from a political family, he is oratorical and held office under Shagari. Apart from these, what other credentials? Is John of the reactionary mold or progressive? Personally, I think he is a conservative. Such a mien is not suitable to address the current I(g)bo predicament.
Pat Utomi, I know he is brilliant and articulate, has cut a niche for himself in the business world. Can he synthesise business with politics? That is what should direct our further thoughts on this man. Again, is he interested in the presidency?
You see that there are a plethora of issues to be tackled. Certain laid down criteria must be clearly spelt out before we can co-opt any I(g)bo for the highest office. One clear criterion though must be an avowed interest in ONE Nigeria, otherwise no show. I agree with you that as we progress, some other names will emerge.
[ March 28, 2001: Message edited by: Osita Chuba ]
Posts: 25 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
Thanks brother yes Pat Utomi may be indeed the dark horse on this list. Like you said at least he has the Economic background that can turn Nigerian Economy from that of comsumption to that of production. However as much as I agree that any of this candidate has to support one Nigeria. However a support of one Nigeria without restructuring of Nigeria may earn him support from the North But it could cost them support in the South.
I don't think Igbos should borrow a leaf from the yorubas, once we get our president Igbo president in mouth then we stop calling for restructuring Nigeria. That will kill the whole thing Igbos are fighting for. My point is that unless we get an Igbo candidate who is bold and pragmatic at the same time, we will not go too far with this. The North are still the power brokers with the current set up. Unless changes are made and Nigeria is restructured they will continue to be power brokers. I do think that the South south will continue to agitate for resource control no matter who is the president. That is where the whole issue will be settled.
posted
Chuba Permit me to tarry a little longer on this Ibo/Igbo issue.While you may trivialize it's importance I think this issue has played a major role in dividing Igboland.
Yes the Irish speak Gaelic and some Jews Yiddish, but the English speak english, the French speak French likewise the Germans speak German.The important thing here is every one of these group chose to be and speak whatever they speak, that is not the case with Ibo and Igbo.
The absence of the alphabet GB in english led to Ibo (after Hibou and Iboe had been tried).Today some outsiders say the Ibo's are different from the Igbo's and this tool has been very effective in the continued division of the people, hence my assertion that the people are the same.You cannot have Ibo for the Deltans and Igbo for the easterners without creating division, so let's revert to the original thing.This is just my thinking and by no means binding.
You say you speak Ika and write Ika, let me remind you that the written Igbo of today came from the translation of the bible into the Bonny version of Igbo, hence for an Igbo of Abakalilki origin the written Igbo ( at least bible version) is as foreign to him as it is to you from the Ika area.Go up to Nsukka and it even get's worse, yet we must continue to cummunicate in Igbo somehow.
Nobody is shoving anything down anybody's throat and definitely no Igbo is superior to the other, but I believe in identification.I will never support coercion of any type as Nigeria has shown that it does not work.
Brother Biafra et al I am not too entusiastic about an Igbo president as it will change nothing if Nigeria remains the way it is.Are the people of the SW not just discovering that? By the time you get an Igbo acceptable to Northern Nigeria, he/she will be so watered down it will just be another Obasanjo with an Igbo name.
posted
I am only posting this b/c the author is also from Delta State like Osita Chuba but he see himself as Delta IGBO.
His words "Just before anybody starts getting any ideas, I must state here that I do not have any relationship with Mr. Odirri. Although I am from Delta state, I am from the Igbo speaking part while Mr. Odirri is an Urhobo. "
The Plight of Odirri By Chuck O. Egbune, Esq.
March 23, 2001 It is very imperative that we all recognize as Martin Luther King once said that "Injustice any where is a threat to justice everywhere." Nigeria is littered with injustice from incessant police brutality to blatant abuse of power. The government might have changed but the same brute force is being applied against Nigerians. For the Nigerian Police, it is business as usual. They still engage in extra judicial killings and even killing the innocent and then labeling them armed robbers so much so that Justice Oputa recently decried the blood tasty Nigeria police. You might have read the debacle or preferably the massacre of innocent students of the University of Lagos by these animals in "uniform of brutality" as the late reggae legend Bob Marley would call the Nigerian police if he had met them. Nigerians are under siege and the earlier those of us in diaspora did something the better. It is quite pertinent to mention here that "the only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing." At this moment, there is a travesty of justice that is going on in Delta state that I would like to bring to the attention of Nigerians. One Mr. Odirri, a lawyer in Lagos was engaged in a war of words with the Governor of Delta state and he said something (which I don't remember now) but whatever he said does not justify what is happening now. The governor did not take kindly to what he said. First the governor's lawyer threatened to sue Mr. Odirri if he did not retract what he said. Then when Mr. Odirri failed to retract, the governor sent policemen from Asaba to Lagos and abducted Mr. Odirri and brought him to Asaba where he is currently being held incommunicado without bail. The governor and his cohorts charged Mr. Odirri with sedition. Just before anybody starts getting any ideas, I must state here that I do not have any relationship with Mr. Odirri. Although I am from Delta state, I am from the Igbo speaking part while Mr. Odirri is an Urhobo. I have never met Mr. Odirri and I am not his errand boy. However, what is happening to Mr. Odirri should concern every Nigerian because it is Mr. Odirri today, it could be any of us tomorrow. As a lawyer practicing here in the U.S., I believe that Mr. Odirri is a victim of the system. The state machinery is being deployed to settle a private score. If the governor was aggrieved, he should have gone to the civil court to seek redress. Even then, I am not sure he should prevail because as a public figure, he should be subjected to a higher standard of proof for defamation. Can Nigerians imagine if the president of the U.S. or any governor here were allowed to arrest and charge a U.S. citizen for saying something bad about them, the jail would be so full that there would be no space for regular criminals. In fact, if Clinton had arrested everybody that made defamatory statements about him, at least 20 million Americans would be in jail. They accuse him of everything including murder and conspiracy yet he persevered. Mr. Odirri's plight has become a crusade for me and I was glad to receive your email talking about human rights. I want to use this opportunity to implore every Nigerian who is perturbed about the malicious state action against Mr. Odirri to sign a petition that I will personally pay for to publish in a reputable Nigerian Newspaper asking Delta state government to reconsider their actions. Many have abandoned Mr. Odirri including his sister but we must not turn a blind eye to this travesty of justice for any precedence set therefore is a slippery slope that would consume many. It is quite disturbing to me that the Federal government and Federal courts would allow this injustice and charade to continue. If you are concerned, please circulate this email to as many people as possible. You may also choose to send email directly to the governor or go to Delta state webpage
[ March 28, 2001: Message edited by: IbIbomn ]
___________________ Nobody drinks medicine on behalf of a sick person.
Posts: 110 | From: United States | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
That was exactly my concern for us having an Igbo President right now. It could do to us what Obasanjo have done to the yorubas. During Abacha time the yorubas were so vocal against the injustices going on in Nigeria. However since Obasanjo came to power those injustice have quadruple yet most of the vocal critic Abacha have now become the most ardent defenders of Obasanjo attrocities whether is odi masacare or Shoot on sight order from Obusonjo to Nigeria Police.
Like you said to get an Igbo candidate who will be acceptable to the North, he has to be a watered down version of Igbo candidate. You will not see any of the so called conservative Igbos get anywhere in the North as a candidate. This is why people like Ike Nwachukwu whom their Igbo credentials are very thin are been considered. The only reason Ike Nwachukwu name is been toss arround is because of his northern herritage. Ike Nwachukwu is a light weight when it comes to Igbo leadership.
In my opinion Igbos interest will be better served in restructuring Nigeria and actualizing Biafra than having a phony Igbo president who will be nothing but a northern appeasement president. Look at what is happening to the Yorubas today Bola Ige have become the resource control antagonist. He is today doing the Federal Government dirty job as Attorney general. Look at what Ojo Maduekwe and people like Mbadinoju are doing to the Igbos those are probably the type of Igbos who will be acceptable to the North.
posted
Chiboy, Thanks for breaking down the issue of Ibo/Igbo for Mr. Chuba's to understand where I was coming from. I do not understand all this quarrel about a simple but very inportant fact. The variation of Igbo language and poeples' (like any other language and race) is as many as the regions and peoples', however there is one standard language, ie Igbo and the people who speak that general language are Igbos. Period. Here in Germany, there's the Bayerisch, Sachsen, Norden and other variations of the spoken German language, (among the Bayerns there is Frankonians) but every German refer to him or herself as "Deutsche" or German in english. That was exactly the point I was making, unfortunately, Mr. Chuba understood it differently. Now to the topic Biafra, I have to disgree with you that the Igbos will make the same mistake the Yorubas are making presently. Any prospective future president of Nigeria be it Igbo or not knows that there is no way he can continue to rule Nigeria as it is presently structured and govern with success. Honestly, I see the Igbo struggle as a two-track struggle --- while we struggle for a seperate Biafran State, we should also participate in which direction Nigeria should go come 2003. When we get one of our own or someone who will be more attentive to our yearnings, he or she will be courageous to start the process of restructuring Nigeria, as a true federal state, or a confederation. Otherwise he or she will have to contend with those will still insist on Biafra, etc. My argurement herein is that we cannot afford to put all our eggs in one basket.The actualisation of Biafra may come before 2003 or thereafter, nevertheless, we should fully participate in deciding how and who governs Nigeria. Probably that is the thinking of the five Southeastern governors and Ohaneze that while they are looking for a suitable candidate to represent Igbos come 2003, they are also supporting Chief Ralph Uwazuruike and MASSOB in their Biafra actualization struggle.This is the two-track strategy I meant. I beleive that that is the wise thing to do, given the slippery political situation in Nigeria. It is good to learn that Emeka Anyaoku was on the Nigerian side during the Civil war. Since that is the case, he, like Ike Nwachukwu must atone for their sins. Meanwhile the search for a suitable candidate and the struggle for Biafra continues; it's two sides of same coin.
Posts: 997 | From: Germany | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
posted
All: Given the depth of our discussion on Ibo/Igbo, I decided to seek further clarification on the issue. My findings show that majority of the folks here are right and I am wrong. I accept. My findings reveal that infact Ibo is a corrupted word for Igbo. I asked further about "the Igbo enwe eze" as compared with the Obis in the Delta Igbo area.
For information, the Aniocha people of Delta State have their kingship from the royal family of Eze Chima, who is said to hail from Benin. Thus, I was a bit confused in this regard. I was then told that the Kingship in this area may have been an imposition, for if the kings came from Bini and the people speak a dialect of Igbo, then something is amiss.
Without much ado, I bow to superior argument but not to the guy who used 'rubbish'.
Posts: 25 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
It takes a bigger man to bow down or bow out and admit that they are wrong. For that I think you are bigger man than you think. For that you have my utmost respect if you don't already have it before now. The argument I think have been very civil. We all are here to learn. On that Note also could you please ask your source why the onitsha or Onichas have Obi also.
You mentioned Aniocha I remember in 1980 in Nigeria during the time of agitation for Anioma state, I remember a group of people from Onitsha at that time expressed interest in becoming part of Anioma state. Their explanation was that People of Aniocha and Onicha were sibblings who were divided by River Niger. can somebody look into this and find out if there is some truth behind this. I can imagine it may be true because Onicha are they only town in Southeast that have an Obi. May be other than Arochukwu calphate.
This is further proof that many have tried to dilute the Igbo nations. Remember that it was only Igbos that strongly resisted the Jihad of Usman dan Fodio, also white found the Igbos very difficult to colonize. Igbos have withstood so many attempt to indoctrinate them into other cultures or even wipe Igbos out completely. However the more they try the stronger we get, just like the energizer bunny we keep ticking.
posted
All: My admission of the misconception of Ibo/Igbo is not borne out of 'guilt' as inferred by the last post, it is from a new comprehension of the matter.
[ March 29, 2001: Message edited by: Osita Chuba ]
Posts: 25 | From: London | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
posted
I am not Igbo but I have followed this debate with a keen interest. Why are you people fussing when the election is still two years away. Don't you guys think that Obasanjo have the 2003 Election already rapped up? all is left is certifying him come 2003. Even your loud mouth brother Arthur Nzeribe is already advocating a single candidate Obasanjo. Who knows Obasanjo may have grease the palm of those that will give him trouble come 2003. Was it not few Months ago that Nzeribe was calling for Obasanjo's impeachment? Now he is promoting his re-election what changed between then and now.
Come on people get a grip the North control the whole process, they pick who is going to be president you guys are just wasting your breath. lets move on to other issues like restructuring Nigeria that is the only way out.
posted
Blaogun, according to you, "Obasanjo has the 2003 election already rapped up, has greased the palms of those that would give him trouble come 2003, and the North control the whole process as they pick who's going to be president". Then you suggested that we should move on to issues like restructuring Nigeria as the only way out.
I understand that you are a pro Nigerian who's okay with the status quo. If Obasanjo's installation for 2003 is a foregone conclusion and the North control the whole process, as you put it, the restructuring you mentioned will be another "stage-management' by the "privileged" which brings you Nigerians back to square one. The pro Nigeria, pro status quo group seem to enjoy endless rounds of vicious cycle where you all claw each other down like captured and helpless crabs at the bottom of the clay pot ready to be cooked.
If the North holds Nigeria's destiny in the palm of his hands and Obasanjo is the best that Nigeria can produce, then Nigeria is not awake to the 21st century neither is he interested in getting there.
As for Arthur Nzeribe, his action is best left to those who can insight farther than the physical eyes. Having Igbo conscious Representatives within Nigeria affairs does not hurt our goal of Biafra Actualization, rather, it enhances it.
posted
Chuba, Since others have praised your big heart and demonstration of what intelligence means, all I can say is yours is an example worth emulating. That you took time to research about Igbo as a word and it's meaning shows how serious you take what we write on this board. No, your admittance bears no guilt, rather, it has the hallmark of an honest man.
Balogun, Please be informed that Nzeribe does not speak for the Igbos. The only umbrella organization that guide the Igbos in their polical route is Ohaneze Ndigbo. If 2003 is so far as you elluded, why are you then concluding that Obasanjo has already won an election which will take place two years from now? Like I said in my last post, even if Osanjo or anyone wins the election of 2003, we, the Igbos unlike the Yorubas will not let up on our demand for a sovereign state of Biafra, or at worst, a restructured Nigeria. How could you talk of restructure when your cousins (Bola Ige & Co) have all sold out to the North you are now accusing of sponsoring Obasanjo? Please do not run away from the truth, the bitter truth is that your people have mortgaged both their conscience and that of all of the south. We must not always blame the North for our (south) cowardice. Nigeria does not belong to the North alone, but it is the dis-oriented South that have always given the North the reason to think that way. An Igboman has every right to contest for the Nigerian presidency whether the North likes it or not. By the way, are you ready to vote for an Igboman come 2003? If yes, could you name who that candidate would be and why you want to vote for him or her. Meanwhile, Ohaneze should forget the Nzeribes and go ahead (which I think they are doing now) and choose a viable candidate and put to Nigeria and let Nigerians decide between him/her and Obasanjo or any other person whom they want to govern Nigeria after 2003. No single person or group of persons should arrogate to themslves the exclusive right of choosing who should rule over 120 million Nigerians. The consensus on this thread so far is that Igbos want Governor Orji Kalu to represent them come 2003. Nevertheless, alutta continu para the actualization of the Republic of Biafra.
posted
Nwa Aro, I am yet to see any evidence that Ohaneze speak for the Igbos. As I wrote in a different tread they do not have grassroot support, Unlike MASSOB which was able to close down Ariaaria Market. Now that is speaking for the Igbos.
Posts: 585 | From: London. | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
posted
Wacko, I'm right there with you, my brother. Ohaneze does not speak for Igbos, they speak for themselves to protect their selfish interests. Rather,its MASSOB that speaks for the Igbos.
___________________ Forward ever, backward never! Posts: 1874 | From: USA | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
Like I have said many times MASSOB is the only Igbo organization that have a grassroot support. And have the gut to shake the status quo in Nigeria. How many Igbo organization from Ohanaeze to Odenigbo have had the gut to even mention Biafra. But MASSOB have raised Biafran Flag. and Continue to talk about Biafra, They have been prisoned they have been arrested, they have been harrassed and yet they are not detered. For me that is what I call a grassroot organization.
Look Ohanaeze can not even agree on what communique of their meeting should say, whether critizing Obasanjo is to soft or too hash. There are so many Obasanjo apologist and errand boys in Ohanaeze that is what their problem is.
posted
An entity or organization that has no guiding principles or a ratified constitution cannot claim to be representing a people's interest. That's the case of Ohaneze. It is a fraudulent organization.
posted
If Igbos from all walks of life had overwhelmingly recognized Uwazuruike's MASSOB, the ongoing mess right now would have been a thing of the past. For Ohaneze, it is as Ojukwu clearly put it: "A bunch of job-seekers" who are there to patronize Obasanjo. I have no single faith in Ohaneze.
Posts: 292 | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged
You are right the only reason Ohanaeze is scared of MASSOb is because MASSOB has more grassroot support than old cargos and job seekers like Ohanaeze. MASSOB doesn't give a dam about Obusonjo and his job. All MASSOB want is self determination not hand outs. That is why Obasanjo is so scared and obssessed with Chief Ralph and MASSOB. I bet you that Obusonju loses sleep at night because of MASSOB.
posted
Biafra: Congratulations! Without being told, you are one pragmatic Igbo. Keep it flowing, brother.
Posts: 481 | From: Buffalo, New York USA | Registered: Mar 2001
| IP: Logged